Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University ›› 2020, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (6): 63-71.doi: 10.6040/j.issn.1673-3770.0.2019.570

Previous Articles     Next Articles

The therapeutic effects of low temperature plasma radiofrequency ablation and CO2 laser surgery on early glottic carcinoma: a Meta-analysis

TAN Fengwu, DENG Yaping, LI Kehua   

  1. Department of Otorhinolaryngology & Head and Neck Surgery, the Affiliated Zhuzhou Hospital of Xiangya School of Medicine CSU, Zhuzhou 412000, Hunan, China
  • Published:2021-01-11

PDF (PC)

189

Abstract: Objective To evaluate the clinical effects of low temperature plasma radiofrequency ablation(LTP-RFA)using a suspension laryngoscope and CO2 laser surgery on early glottic carcinoma by a meta-analysis. Methods Related literature was retrieved from electronic databases, including PubMed, EMbase, Medline, VIP, Wanfang, and CNKI, from inception to June 1st, 2019. At the same time, the reference lists of the enrolled articles were retrieved manually. Literature comparing the therapeutic effects of LTP-RFA using a suspension laryngoscope and CO2 laser surgery on early glottic carcinoma was retrieved according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Literature screening, data extraction, and literature evaluation were carried out by two authors independently. Revman 5.3 software was adopted for meta-analysis. Results A total of 10 studies involving 1 055 patients were enrolled. Meta-analysis results suggested that, compared with CO2 laser surgery, LTP-RFA significantly reduced the operative time ［SMD =-2.97, 95%CI(-4.05, -1.90), P<0.00 001］, shortened the postoperative mucosal recovery time ［OR=5.53, 95%CI(2.84, 10.78), P<0.00 001］and increased intraoperative blood loss ［SMD=-0.73, 95%CI(0.09, 0.71), P=0.01］. In addition, there were no statistically significant differences in recurrence rate ［OR=0.79, 95%CI(0.46, 1.36), P=0.39］, degree of postoperative pain ［SMD=-0.17, 95%CI(-0.43, 0.08), P=0.18］, and postoperative voice quality ［SMD=-0.21, 95%CI(-1.13, 0.71), P=0.65］ between the two methods. However, sensitivity analysis results revealed that this conclusion may not be robust. No obvious publication bias was detected in the funnel plot regarding the operative time and recurrence rate. Conclusion LTP-RFA has a superior effect over CO2 laser surgery in treating early glottic carcinoma in terms of operative time and postoperative mucosal recovery, but LTP-RFA has greater intraoperative blood. There are no statistically significant differences in recurrence rate, postoperative pain degree, and postoperative voice quality between these two approaches.

Key words: Plasma radiofrequency ablation, CO2 laser, Early glottic carcinoma, Meta-analysis, Therapy

CLC Number: 

  • R765.21
[1] Du LB, Mao WM, Chen WQ, et al. Incidence and mortality of larynx cancer in China during 2003-2007[J]. Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi, 2012, 33(4): 395-398. PMID: 22781413.
[2] Hoffman HT, Porter K, Karnell LH, et al. Laryngeal cancer in the United States: changes in demographics, patterns of care, and survival[J]. Laryngoscope, 2006, 116(9 Pt 2 Suppl 111): 1-13. doi:10.1097/01.mlg.0000236095.97947.26.
[3] 季文樾, 杜强, 关超, 等. 1115例喉癌患者的生存分析[J]. 中华耳鼻咽喉科杂志, 2004, 39(1): 17-19. doi: 10.3760/j.issn:1673-0860.2004.01.005. JI Wenyue, DU Qiang, GUAN Chao, et al. Survival analysis of 1115 patients with laryngeal carcinoma[J]. Chinese Journal of Otorhinolaryngology, 2004, 39(1): 17-19. doi: 10.3760/j.issn:1673-0860.2004.01.005.
[4] O'Hara J, Markey A, Homer JJ. Transoral laser surgery versus radiotherapy for tumour stage 1a or 1b glottic squamous cell carcinoma: systematic review of local control outcomes[J]. J Laryngol Otol, 2013, 127(8): 732-738. doi:10.1017/S0022215113001400.
[5] van Loon Y, Sjögren EV, Langeveld TPM, et al. Functional outcomes after radiotherapy or laser surgery in early glottic carcinoma: a systematic review[J]. Head Neck, 2012, 34(8): 1179-1189. doi:10.1002/hed.21783.
[6] American Society of Clinical Oncology, Pfister DG, Laurie SA, et al. American Society of Clinical Oncology clinical practice guideline for the use of larynx-preservation strategies in the treatment of laryngeal cancer[J]. J Clin Oncol, 2006, 24(22): 3693-3704. doi:10.1200/JCO.2006.07.4559.
[7] Stuart Strong M. Laser excision of carcinoma of the larynx[J]. Laryngoscope, 1975, 85(8): 1286-1289. doi:10.1288/00005537-197508000-00003.
[8] Brndbo K, Benninger MS. Laser resection of T1a glottic carcinomas: results and postoperative voice quality[J]. Acta Otolaryngol, 2004, 124(8): 976-979. doi:10.1080/00016480410017413.
[9] Timms MS, Bruce IA, Patel NK. Radiofrequency ablation(coblation): a promising new technique for laryngeal papillomata[J]. J Laryngol Otol, 2007, 121(1): 28-30. doi:10.1017/S0022215106003069.
[10] Carney AS, Evans AS, Mirza S, et al. Radiofrequency coblation for treatment of advanced laryngotracheal recurrent respiratory papillomatosis[J]. J Laryngol Otol, 2010, 124(5): 510-514. doi:10.1017/S00222151099-92398.
[11] 张庆丰, 刘得龙, 宋伟, 等. 等离子射频消融术治疗早期声门型喉癌的疗效观察[J]. 临床耳鼻咽喉头颈外科杂志, 2011, 25(18): 855-856. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1001-1781.2011.18.013.
[12] 陈刚, 赵华, 荆建军, 等. 显微支撑喉镜下等离子消融治疗早期声门型喉癌11例[J]. 山东大学耳鼻喉眼学报, 2012, 26(4): 24-26. doi: CNKI:SUN:SDYU.0.2012-04-010. CHEN Gang, ZHAO Hua, JING Jianjun, et al. Glottic carcinoma at early stage treated by microscopic suspension laryngoscopy combined with a coblation technique: a report of 11 cases[J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2012, 26(4): 24-26. doi: CNKI:SUN:SDYU.0.2012-04-010.
[13] 刘敏, 牛广宪. 低温等离子射频消融术治疗早期声门型喉癌疗效分析[J]. 听力学及言语疾病杂志, 2015, 23(4): 422-423. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1006-7299.2015.04.024.
[14] 徐夏, 邓文婷, 黄成志, 等. 喉内镜下等离子消融术与开放性手术治疗早期喉癌的疗效对比[J]. 山东大学耳鼻喉眼学报, 2019, 33(2): 81-85. doi: CNKI:SUN:SDYU.0.2019-02-017. XU Xia, DENG Wenting, HUANG Chengzhi, et al. Curative effect analysis of endoscopic laryngeal surgery with plasma radiofrequency ablation versus open surgery to treat early glottic cancer[J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2019, 33(2): 81-85. doi: CNKI:SUN:SDYU.0.2019-02-017.
[15] Shuang Y, Li C, Zhou X, et al. Outcomes of radiofrequency ablation(RFA)and CO2 laser for early glottic cancer[J]. Am J Otolaryngol, 2016, 37(4): 311-316. doi:10.1016/j.amjoto.2016.03.002.
[16] Zhang Y, Wang BR, Sun GB, et al. Carbon dioxide laser microsurgery versus low-temperature plasma radiofrequency ablation for T1a glottic cancer: a single-blind randomized clinical trial[J]. Biomed Res Int, 2018, 2018: 4295960. doi:10.1155/2018/4295960.
[17] 信鑫. 微创手术治疗早期声门型喉癌及癌前病变的近期疗效观察[D]. 长春: 吉林大学, 2013.
[18] 周天骄. 等离子射频消融手术对早期声门型喉癌的疗效[D]. 上海: 上海交通大学, 2014.
[19] 周津徽,王成禹. CO2激光和等离子射频消融术应用于早期声门型喉癌治疗中对相关手术指标、疼痛及复发情况的影响[J]. 中国全科医学, 2018, 21(z1): 200-202. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.z1.085. ZHOU Jinhui, WANG Chengyu. Effects of CO2 laser and plasma radiofrequency ablation on related surgical indexes, pain and recurrence in the treatment of early laryngeal cancer[J]. Chinese General Practice, 2018, 21(z1): 200-202. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.z1.085.
[20] 李毅, 王克. 内镜下低温等离子射频消融术治疗早期声门型喉癌的临床观察[J]. 肿瘤基础与临床, 2018, 31(1): 71-73. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5412.2018.01.023.
[21] 胡莲花. 比较CO2激光与等离子射频消融术治疗早期声门型喉癌的疗效[J]. 按摩与康复医学, 2016, 7(22): 36-37.
[22] 赵斐斐, 赵琳, 崔晓波, 等. 低温等离子与CO2激光微创治疗早期声门型喉癌疗效及安全性比较[J]. 现代生物医学进展, 2016, 16(36): 7087-7090. doi:10.13241/j.cnki.pmb.2016.36.022. ZHAO Feifei, ZHAO Lin, CUI Xiaobo, et al. Comparison of efficacy and safety of microtherm plasma radio frequency and CO2 laser in treatment of early glottic squamous cell carcinoma[J]. Progress in Modern Biomedicine, 2016, 16(36): 7087-7090. doi:10.13241/j.cnki.pmb.2016.36.022.
[23] 赵春红, 李玉杰, 于敏, 等. CO2激光与等离子射频消融术治疗早期声门型喉癌疗效比较[J]. 听力学及言语疾病杂志, 2015, 23(3): 307-309. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-7299.2015.03.0023.
[24] 陈柯帆, 黄义, 任丽君. 低温等离子射频消融术及CO2激光治疗早期喉癌及癌前病变效果比较[J]. 现代仪器与医疗, 2018, 24(3): 17-19. doi:10.11876/mimt201803008. CHEN Kefan, HUANG Yi, REN Lijun. Effect comparison of low-temperature plasma radiofrequency ablation and CO2laser surgery in the treatment of early laryngeal carcinoma and precancerous lesions[J]. Modern Instruments &Mediccal Treatment, 2018, 24(3): 17-19. doi:10.11876/mimt201803008.
[25] 李为民, 王荣光, 黄冬雁, 等. 低温等离子射频消融术治疗喉部恶性肿瘤的临床疗效[J]. 中国老年学杂志, 2015, 35(6): 1449-1451. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-9202.2015.06.005. LI Weimin, WANG Rongguang, HUANG Dongyan, et al. The efficacy of transoral coblation microsurgery for laryngocarcinoma[J]. Chinese Journal of Gerontology, 2015, 35(6): 1449-1451. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-9202.2015.06.005.
[26] 张诠, 欧阳电. 喉癌显微激光手术学的发展及其制约因素[J]. 中华临床医师杂志(电子版), 2012, 6(2): 285-287. doi:10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0785.2012.02.003.
[27] Motta G, Esposito E, Cassiano B, et al. T1-T2-T3 glottic tumors: fifteen years experience with CO2 laser[J]. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl, 1997, 527: 155-159. doi:10.3109/00016489709124062.
[28] Thomas JV, Olsen KD, Neel HB 3rd, et al. Early glottic carcinoma treated with open laryngeal procedures[J]. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 1994, 120(3): 264-268. doi:10.1001/archotol.1994.01880270012003.
[29] Tsunoda K, Soda Y, Tojima H, et al. Stroboscopic observation of the larynx after radiation in patients with T1 glottic carcinoma[J]. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl, 1997, 527: 165-166. doi:10.3109/00016489709124064.
[30] Hartl DM, Brasnu DF. Contemporary surgical management of early glottic cancer[J]. Otolaryngol Clin North Am, 2015, 48(4): 611-625. doi:10.1016/j.otc.2015.04.007.
[31] Moustapha S, Olivier D, Alexandre B, et al. Laser endoscopic microsurgery of laryngeal cancers[J]. Int Arch Otorhinolaryngol, 2014, 18(1): 36-38. doi:10.1055/s-0033-1361084.
[32] Carney AS, Timms MS, Marnane CN, et al. Radiofrequency coblation for the resection of head and neck malignancies[J]. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 2008, 138(1): 81-85. doi:10.1016/j.otohns.2007.08.022.
[33] Remacle M, Eckel HE, Antonelli A, et al. Endoscopic cordectomy. A proposal for a classification by the working committee, European laryngological society[J]. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol, 2000, 257(4): 227-231. doi:10.1007/s004050050228.
[1] LI Dingbo, TANG Zhiyuan, DENG Zhiyi, ZENG Xianhai, ZHANG Qiuhang, WANG Zaixing. Curative effect analysis of low-temperature plasma radiofrequency ablation in 27 cases of drug-related rhinitis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(5): 11-17.
[2] LI Shijin, TANG Angcang, YANG Bi, WANG Jianglan, LIU Longqian. Long-term effectiveness of virtual reality-based vision therapy for convergence insufficiency:a random clinical trial [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(5): 35-40.
[3] LI Lijie, TIAN Xiufen. Forty cases of early glottic cancer treated by CO2 laser surgery combined with radiofrequency ablation [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(4): 79-85.
[4] WANG MeiOverview,LI ZhihaiGuidance. Laryngeal cancer stem cells: potential therapeutic targets for overcoming multidrug resistance [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(4): 120-128.
[5] WANG Huan, HU Li,YU Hongmeng. Research progress of olfactory dysfunction in chronic rhinosinusitis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(3): 43-49.
[6] LIN Manqing, ZHOU Min, CHEN Tengyu, LI-Dan, FANG Caishan, WANG Ruizhi, ZHU Jinxiang, RUAN-Yan, XU Huixian, WANG Peiyuan. Meta-analysis of the efficacy and safety of traditional Chinese medicine for nasal irrigation in the treatment of chronic rhinosinusitis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(3): 209-225.
[7] JIANG Xuelian, ZHANG Jingyue, WEI Xudong. Evaluation of the efficacy and potential mechanism of biyuan tongqiao granules in chronic sinusitis treatment based on Meta-analysis bridging network pharmacology [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(3): 226-236.
[8] HUANG Kaiyue, LI Xueqing, HAN Gouxin, ZHANG Qinxiu. Meta-analysis of acupoint catgut embedding in the treatment of allergic rhinitis based on the theory of “lung and spleen” [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(3): 266-274.
[9] LIU Shanshan, HAN Shujing, WANG Xiaoxu, LI Yanhong, NI Xin, ZHANG Jie. Hearing loss in children after bacterial meningitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(1): 48-54.
[10] PANG Chong, BIAN Sainan, ZHANG Bing, YIN Xu, LU Yingxia, YE Pengfei, WANG Zhan, ZHAO Jing, GAO Yan, GUAN Kai. Short-term effect of Dermatophagoides farinae specific sublingual immunotherapy for children with allergic rhinitis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(1): 70-74.
[11] LI Menghui, ZHI Lili, QI Kaiwen, WANG Shanshan, GAO Qian, BU Meiling,. Clinical research of subcutaneous immunotherapy on children with allergic asthma caused by dust mites and combined with mold allergen [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2022, 36(1): 75-80.
[12] LIU Yi, YU Mingkun, SUN Wei, SHAO Zhen, HU Yuanyuan, BI Hongsheng. The effectiveness and safety of orthokeratology on controlling myopia of children: a meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2021, 35(6): 92-100.
[13] ZHONG Liping, GUAN Xilong, WANG Jingjing, TANG Yong. Intratympanic injections and systemic glucocorticoid treatment for sudden hearing loss: a systematic review and Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2021, 35(5): 1-10.
[14] CHEN Guoping, FU Minyi, YE Fei, XU Jianhui. Comparative study of holmium and CO2 laser surgeries for early glottic carcinoma [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2021, 35(4): 8-11.
[15] NIU Zijie, XIAO Yang,WANG Jun,MA Lijinng. Progress in the surgical treatment of recurrent laryngeal papillomatosis [J]. Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University, 2021, 35(4): 96-100.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] . [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2006, 20(2): 116 -118 .
[2] ZHOU Zi-ning,JIN Guo-wei . [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2006, 20(5): 462 -465 .
[3] ZHOU Bin,LI Bin . Endoscopic sinus surgery for 75 patients with chronic sinusitis and nasal polyps[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2006, 20(1): 24 -26 .
[4] XU Sainan,YANG Lei . Apoptosis of epithelial cells in nasal polyps promoted by erythromycin[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2006, 20(1): 27 -29 .
[5] . [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2006, 20(1): 94 -95 .
[6] LIU Lian-he . Treatment of deep neck abscess in 37 cases[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2008, 22(2): 180 -181 .
[7] . [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2008, 22(3): 200 -203 .
[8] QIAO Yi,NI Guan-sen,CHEN Wen-wen . Effect of H-UPPP and nasal operations on obstructive sleep apnea syndrome in 38 cases
[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2008, 22(3): 206 -208 .
[9] WANG Xiao-feng,LIN Chang,CHENG Jin-mei . Expression of ABAD in inner ears and its clinical significance in different age mice[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2008, 22(3): 207 -211 .
[10] FAN Qi-jun,HUANG Zhi-wu,MEI Ling,XIAO Bo-kui . Expression of the heat shock protein 27 in rat cochlea induced by sodium salicylate injection by the FQ-PCR technique[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (OTOLARYNGOLOGY AND OPHTHALMOLOGY), 2008, 22(3): 212 -214 .
Website Copyright: Editorial Office of Journal of Otolaryngology and Ophthalmology of Shandong University
Address: No.27 Shanda South Road, Jinan, Shandong, China. Post code: 250100 Tel: +86-0531-88366912 Email: ebhxb@sdu.edu.cn Supported by Beijing Magtech Co.Ltd